Sunday, May 18, 2008

To Love, But Not To Hold

After many reviews I received of this movie and the full-house attendances at the theatre, I finally succumbed and watched Ayat-Ayat Cinta today - commonly translated as "Verses of Love" but after watching it, I thought an Arabic translation as "Proofs of Love" seemed more accurate.

The jury on Ayat-Ayat Cinta is still out there. What seemed to divide these diverging views is firstly on the issue of polygamy portrayed in the movie. After watching it today, I opined that to be a dense perception of the whole point the movie was about and the message it was trying to portray. I also differ on the other contentious point that it was a religious love story - it was a love story as universal as any other, irrespective of faith - and it was literally illustrated in the movie when the Muslim male lead married his second wife, who is an Egyptian Coptic Christian.

At the core of this movie is truly the story of true love - each of its character trying to achieve the level of selflessness, purity and unadulterated love that he/she yearns. It represents the journey which all of us embark - but the marked consciousness of the characters in journeying through this is remarkable. None of the decisions they made were easy ones: Fahri's decision to be married with the right wife, Maria's silent suffering for the love of her life, Aisha's consent to her husband's second marriage ... and the list goes on even with the other minor characters.

It was about searching, and for some blessed ones amongst us, finding what we seek. But despite, the movie reminds us of faith when we don't get what we want. A moving example is when the accused in the same prison cell with Fahri spoke of the tests faced by Prophet Joseph (as) as inspiration to move on and to remain steadfast of our faith in The Almighty. A poignant point was delivered by Maria, when on her deathbed and despite being married to Fahri, she finally understood the difference between loving and holding on to the one whom she loves - hence the title of this entry.

But love is not simply a bed of roses, and neither is faith. We have to work to acquire and maintain faith. True love, requires sacrifices. Each of the character displayed an understanding of this concept remarkably. At the end of the movie, despite them not arriving at the audience's ideal life's conclusion, we somehow feel happy and relieved for them because they have arrived at their own mecca, on their own terms, and that is sufficient. These are indeed "Proofs of Love".

It was only after this, that the issue of faith comes into the picture for me, if I must. The virtues spoke of, the misconceptions cleared - are well-known. The 2 concepts which permeated through this movie: patience and sincerity, were beautifully exemplified - but the characters need not necessarily be Muslims to proof that point.

I have not read the novel of which this film was based on, but I suspect that in many years to come when the euphora of the movie has subsided, it will remain a classic when the public matures through the literal aspects of the novel to understand the subtlety of the powerful love messages Habiburrahman El Shirazy intended.

I like the movie, a lot. Perhaps I am a sucker for such things, well...

A bonus reason is that it has Ungu's song at the conclusion: Tercipta Untukku (t: You Were Created For Me). Now, what is there not to like :)

11 comments:

Anonymous said...

I managed to catch this movie yesterday. I thought it was beautiful and moving, I like it. Especially the scene in the cell and when Maria passed on, while in her prayers.

Al-Majnun said...

i have read the book, and it moved me that much more so... definitely a recommended read, Shaykh.

if you found the movie worth contemplating, I find the book even more sublime in the message it intended to send... on the purity of love, and on the whole message of love in Islam as it is to be lived, especially among our youths...

Haiz... i can gush all day about it. But if you succumbed to the temptation of the movie, I am sure you will be even more enthralled by the book.

Haha...

Al-Majnun said...

just realised i said the same thing in three different paragraphs. haha.
apologies for spamming.

Lampu said...

wahaha. Sorry. I am really tickled by men's reactions to this movie. I agree that the movie taught a lot about love and sacrifice. It evoked me in many ways. There are so many scenes in which I was moved to tears. But. It seriously failed to provoke me in any way. And this is disappointing, given all the hype and raving reviews that the film had received. Anyway. That's my 2 cents worth. :) Take cover! hehe

Nunbun said...

I wanted to watch this, but ended up watching Harold And Kumar Escape from Guantanamo. There was a poignant and beautiful lesson from Harold and Kumar - "Leave your brains at the toilet". I'll probably watch Cinta on vcd. If ever.

Al-Majnun said...

book better than movie. haha.

dew embun said...

I echo Nizar...bok better than movie.
Seriously.

A Minah Speaks said...

The "meanest" ustaz in town succumbed to watch the movie.
The prison scene when Fahri was attempting to pray (how many times did he do the Takbir?) reminded me of the countless times its said that we only think of Allah when we're "in trouble". I'm so super guilty of that!!
That scene reminded me of Shaykh Samaan as well. sigh....

Anonymous said...

Aside from all the learnings pointed out by The Hoopoe, this is a movie that have you reflect on husband/wife responsibilities to each other, about fairness, and about Allah's greatest gift to all women - STRENGTH made of steel.

TheHoopoe said...

little miss pinky,

inspired after our talk at Starbucks? hahahaha

Anonymous said...

Starbucks? What conversation at Starbucks?